BLOG POST #5 TEXT TO TEXT
In Middlesex
and Macbeth knifes are phallic
symbols. Phallic symbols are objects that represent penises. Knifes as phallic
symbols illustrate male dominance because they hold the penises, or knifes,
which shows they hold power and authority. Although in Middlesex and Macbeth,
the knife represents different actions, its important to notice that penises
are often compared to knifes.
This theory originates
from Sigmud Freud, an Austrian neurologist who studies dreams. He concluded
that dreams directly effected human’s actions. He created the theory that every long objected in
a dream was in some way a phallic symbol. In Macbeth by William Shakespeare, Macbeth is told by witches a
prophecy that he will be crowned king. He was dreaming of a dagger and said, “Is this
a dagger which I see before me,… To feeling as to sight? Or art thou but a
dagger of the mind, a false creation.” (2.1.40) He is trying to figure out if
he is dreaming or if he really has a dagger in his hand. As he is trying to
discover what is happening he says, “Thou marshall’st me the way that I was
going, and such an instrument I was to use” (2.1.45-46). This dagger symbolizes Macbeth’s penis because
he wants to succeed the throne and he will be able to by producing offspring.
The instrument he is going to use is his penis with lady Macbeth to produce
children.
In Middlesex,
by Jeffery Eugnides Callie compares Jerome’s penis to a knife. Callie does not
want to engage in sex with Jerome and does not enjoy it. Callie has sex with
Jerome to make his sister jealous. After they have sex she says. “Pain. Pain
like a knife…it ripped into me. It spread up my belly all the way to my
nipples” (375). She experiences pain from having sex with Jerome, as if a knife
was cutting into her. This shows that Jerome has a lot of strength and power
over her and is using his “knife” in advantage to himself.
Clearly the knifes symbolizes
different actions, but its interesting to note that penises are metaphorically
compared to knifes in all different types of literature. These two texts are
very different, but it’s so fascinating that they use the same symbol.

